|
2008 LED Bike Lights Comprehensive Review - Intro
By James Sharp
It seems like it was a very short time ago that I was
sitting down writing my review of LED lights for 2007... and yet, so many
improvements have been made. In general, in the few short months since the last
review LEDs have become more efficient, more manufacturers have embraced their
use and price spread has ... well, there is actually a bigger difference between
the most expensive and the least!
This time around, though, I need to have a little preamble. I'll mention the
beams, but mostly I'm going to let the images do the talking -- and there are
quite a few images. As per the norm, there are beam shots in an off road
environment. The surveyor flags are spaced 20ft apart. At 100ft from the
lights, there is a group of three flags. All of the lights, whether it appears
this way or not, were aimed at this 100ft mark. In addition to this, we're
adding images of the lights aimed at a target. The outer circle of the target
is 3ft in diameter. There are two more circles that are 2ft and 1ft in
diameter. The hash marks are located every 2 inches. The lights were 16" from
the target. The camera was behind the target, in line with the lights. This
image shows the difference in light spread -- the more circles lit up, the wider
the beam. Next up are two graphs, one is a line plot that illustrates the beam
spread and color. The other plot is a 3D plot made from the target images. The
height of the 3D plot is the intensity. The more white you see, the brighter
the light is. Finally, each light has a graph of run time. Using all of these
images and graphs, I hope to leave you with a good idea of how the light outputs
compare.
Another change from the last review, we only have three categories: Single Emitter, Dual Emitter, and Large Cluster. The self contained lights will be placed along side their separate-battery siblings.
The single emitters are:
DiNotte 200L,
Light and Motion Stella 180-L,
NiteRider Minewt.X2,
NiteRider Solmate,
Exposure Lights Joystick MaXx
The dual emitters are:
NiteRider MiNewt.X2 Dual,
DiNotte 200L Dual,
Exposure Lights Race MaXx,
Knog Gator 605,
BR Lights C2.1H,
Ay Up lights LCP4N in both spot and
intermediate versions,
BR Lights Jeni-H
The large array lights have more than two emitters. Last winter, that meant
three or four emitters. Now, there are as many as seven! They are:
Lupine Betty,
DiNotte 600L,
Lupine Wilma,
NiteRider TriNewt,
Exposure Lights Enduro MaXx,
Light On! Expedition 1000,
DiNotte Dual 600L
Not one of these lights is the same as last year. It's a clean slate, let's
see how they stack up!
Single Emitter
Dual Emitter
Large Array
 (click the image for a larger view)
James Sharp is a contributing editor for GearReview.com; more of his ramblings and a look at upcoming reviews can be found at his blog -- Lactic Acid Threshold.
|